As expected SP-BSP have announced they will fight 38-38 in UP and 2 each they will leave for RLD and Congress. They are hoping for a simple mathematical calculation & think they will get something between 40-45% votes in UP LS elections.
Whenever I think about SP-BSP alliance my mind goes back to 2011-12 when I started taking interest in politics. 2012 UP election was primarily a contest between SP & BSP and the 1st news came out on news channels after SP's victory was "Dalit Huts" were burnt in the midnight after the election results were announced. Leaders and workers may forget these incidents because it's about their survival but can the common people forget & forgive these ? The answer is NO.
TAKE AWAYS FROM THE BY POLLS
The Gathbandhan got shaped after the successful experiment in Gorakhpur, Phoolpur and Kairana. In Gorakhpur & Phoolpur the voter's turnout was too low to come to any conclusion but Kairana was interesting though. Despite entire opposition coming together the victory margin for Tabassum Hasan was less than 45000 which is too low for LS seats.
In July last yr i was in Delhi one of my college friend from Shamli (Kairna) was in Delhi for his work his father in law is a member of RLD. We planned a get together with other college friends in Gurgaon.
One of them asked me "Bhatt ji kya lag raha hai is bar?".
I said " kuch nhi, 2024 tak to Modi hi hai"
Friend- " Kya bat kar rahe ho yar sab to mil gaye hain, kaise rahega Modi"
I said " Inke milne ka asar sirf tak hai. Baki jagah to sab same hi hai. UP me BJP shayad 40 se neeche rahegi or MP, Raj me thoda bahut loss hoga. But iski recovery ka jugad unhone Northeast ,Orissa & Bengal se pehle hi kar lia hai"
The friend from Shamli intervened "Bhatt ji agar sirf Kairana ki wajah se 40 de rahe ho to bada lo"
I asked curiously, " Why?"
He said "Yaha to is bar #GannaVsJinnah ho gaya tha, Ganne k paise diye nhi Yogi ne or poster chapwa diye. Ek bar sabak sikhana jaruri tha. Ab sab thik hai"
This coming from a relative of RLD member from Kairana is a big statement in my opinion.
Ideally I should have finished by now but two incidents in last two days urges me to write more.
PRIYANKA Factor
Some experts say Priyanka' entry will hurt BJP a lot. Their presumption is based on a FUNNY theory that all MUSLIMS will still vote for the SP-BSP alliance only but a large chunk of Upper caste will go to the Cong now reducing BJP's vote share.
What I have seen in last 12-15 yrs is the upper caste has never voted as a vote bank especially the Brahmins on whom these experts are banking on. They have always voted for those whom they feel are best among available options for state as well as for the country. In 2007 they voted for Mayawati, 2009 due to the weak BJP leadership they voted for Congress, in 2012 they felt cheated by BSP and due to appeasement politlcies of Congress and weak leadership of BJP they had no other choice but SP. By 2014 they realised SP is worst when it comes to appeasement and they are with BJP since then. And as long as BJP puts nation first they aren't going to go anywhere else because they have seen the appeasement policies of other parties. 2017 UP elections is the prime example of this where the cong party made a SHIELA DIXIT their CM candidate but half way into the elections realised that it's not going help them and they decided to go with Akhilesh.I feel the MUSLIMS are more likely to break away from the alliance if the Cong comes out with a strong candidate in muslim majority area because they are the ones who are not happy with any of the 3 parties but going with them only due to the fear of BJP.
Recent surveys
Midway writing this article I came across opinion polls of C voter and Karvy where they are giving SP-BSP alliance 50+ seats and 75 seats if Cong also joins the Gathbandhan. They are saying 45%+ votes for the Gathbandhan and 55+% if Congress joins them which suggests that they are working with mathematical calculation only ignoring chemistry where not only the workers but voters of the two parties were thirsty for each other's blood. As I said workers may forget & forgive but will the voter ?? The answer is NO.
So the statement 40 se jyada bada lo coming from a Jaat living in Shamli whose father in law is in RLD forces me to say BJP is getting 50-60 seats in UP despite all types of Gathbandhan or Mahagathbandhan.
Thanks and Regards,
Himanshu Bhatt